Why Do We Say Mizmor L’Todah on Tisha B’Av?

Why Do We Say Mizmor L’Todah on Tisha B’Av?

The Levush says that Mizmor L’Todah should be recited in a joyous melody because it expresses our gratitude over Hashem’s ongoing chesed with us. It would seem inappropriate to recite it on any fast day, let alone Tisha B’Av. Yet most (not all!) congregations recite it. How is its message compatible with the spirit of the day?

Marei Mekomos for the shiur at https://www.dropbox.com/s/z3m1hkgqrdf6csf/Mizmor%20LTodah%20Tisha%20BAv%20Marei%20Mekomos.pdf?dl=0

Addendum to the Marei Mekomos:
וצאת הכאב מהלב היא תענוג למתאבל כלשון הרמב”ם “כי לאבלים נחת בבכייתם ועוררות אבלם עד כלות כוחותיהם הגופניים, מלסבול אותו המאורע הנפשיי, כמו שיש לבעלי השמחה נחת במיני השחוק. ולפיכך חננתה התורה (לשבויה היפת תואר) ואיפשרה לה זאת עד שתלאה מן הבכי והאבל”

מורה נבוכים ח”ג סוף פרק מא


You may also like

The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 11
00:26:02
/
The R' Aharon Ben Meir - R' Sa'adia Gaon ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 10
00:12:44
/
The R' Aharon Ben Meir - R' Sa'adia Gaon ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 9
00:37:21
/
The R' Aharon Ben Meir - R' Sa'adia Gaon ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 8
00:20:23
/
The great Eretz Yisroel-Bavel Conference, ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 7
00:23:57
/
What was developing over time? The series is ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 6
00:28:03
/
The Ninth Century Letter of the Reish Galusa ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 5
00:26:39
/
A New Theory: Four Stages of the Luach: Prior ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 4
00:23:34
/
Groundless opinions of Maskilim, Grounded ...
The Gates of the Jewish Calendar part 3
00:20:32
/
Who Invented the Luach? The series is based ...
Tisha b'Av Program/Kinnos 5783
02:19:43
/
Tisha b'Av Proram and Kinnos at Cong. Anshei ...
Page 5 of 10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *